Resources — Article

Has Black Friday lost its value? Six years of prices suggest the opposite.

A widespread impression, checked against six years of prices.

Are the discounts really less attractive than they used to be? We analyzed the prices of more than 1,000 products on Amazon.ca, from 2020 to 2025. The results hold a few surprises. Above all, they help you understand when to buy, and how to recognize a real bargain.

Gabriel TasséVP Strategy & Innovation at Tink, lecturer at HEC Montréal. Published .

Pencil drawing: hands grab at a stack of cardboard boxes, in front of a blurred crowd streaked with burgundy.
Contents

Article by Gabriel Tassé, published on gabrieltasse.com · https://gabrieltasse.com/en/resources/is-black-friday-worth-waiting-for

Every November, it’s the same story. The promotions arrive, the discounts multiply, and so do the warnings.

We are reminded that a 30% discount is not necessarily a good deal. That some products cost less a few weeks earlier. That retailers can raise their prices before cutting them.

These warnings are useful. But they also feed a fairly widespread impression: Black Friday is not what it used to be. The promotions have supposedly become less generous, and real bargains rarer and rarer.

I wanted to check whether that impression holds up against the numbers.

To do so, we analyzed the price histories of 1,055 popular products on Amazon.ca, across 19 categories. Six editions of Black Friday, from 2020 to 2025, and 2,215 product-year observations in all.

The result surprised me.

Could the discounts have become more attractive?

In 2020, 19% of the products studied reached their best price of the year, or close to it, during Black Friday. In 2025, that share reached 32%.

The rise was not steady. In 2021, at the height of the pandemic-related disruptions, the share even fell to 17%. It then climbed gradually to reach its highest level in 2025.

And it is not the only indicator that improved.

In six years, the share of products offered at a historically advantageous price rose from 38% to 53%. The share of products sold at least 10% below their usual price also rose, from 36% to 48%.

Good prices are more and more common on Black Friday
  1. 2020: 38%
  2. 2021: 38%
  3. 2022: 43%
  4. 2023: 43%
  5. 2024: 49%
  6. 2025: 53%

In normal times: about 32%, almost unchanged from year to year

Source: Keepa price history, Amazon.ca, Black Friday 2020 to 2025.

LinkedInX

That sits rather poorly with the idea of a Black Friday that keeps losing its value.

Some caution is still in order. We studied each year’s popular products, and those change over time. Part of the improvement could therefore come from the makeup of the sample.

We tried to limit this bias by comparing the same products between the start and the end of the period. Across 169 products in common, we still see a rise, from 21% to 29%. A smaller sample, made up of 34 products present in all six years, does not clearly confirm the trend, however.

So we cannot conclude that every retailer offers better discounts than before. Our study covers Amazon.ca only, not Canadian retail as a whole.

But the data at least invite us to question the impression that bargains necessarily get less attractive from one year to the next.

A good time to buy, rarely the best

The other important finding concerns Black Friday’s advantage over the rest of the year.

Across the six editions studied, 44% of products were among their most advantageous prices during the event. Over an ordinary period of the same length, that share was only 32%.

That is not trivial. In our sample, waiting for Black Friday really does raise your chances of landing a good price.

But when you look for the lowest price of the whole year, the picture changes: only 23% of observations reach that yearly low, or close to it.

Your chances of getting a good deal
  • Lowest price of the year, or close to it

    23% during Black Friday
    12% in normal times
  • Good price (costs more at least three quarters of the year)

    44% during Black Friday
    32% in normal times

Share of the products tracked. “In normal times”: an eleven-day period picked at random elsewhere in the year.

Source: Keepa price history, Amazon.ca, Black Friday 2020 to 2025.

LinkedInX

In other words, you can get a real discount in November and discover, a few months later, that the product sold for even less.

Does that make it a bad deal?

Not necessarily.

The best price of the year is easy to identify when you look back. It is much harder when you are in front of your shopping cart, on a Friday night in November.

We need to learn to tell two things apart: paying a good price, and managing to pay the absolute lowest price.

LinkedInX

And that is where a simple discount percentage can become misleading.

Why a 30% discount doesn’t necessarily mean a good deal

Take a vacuum usually listed at $200.

During Black Friday, its price drops to $140. The tag proudly announces 30% off.

At first glance, you save $60. Hard not to be tempted.

Except that its price history shows it sold for around $145 for a good part of the year. It even dropped to $130 a few times.

The 30% discount does exist relative to the $200 price. But it describes rather poorly what we save relative to the price this product usually sells for.

This example is fictional. In the real data of our study, though, we find similar situations.

In 2021, a Kinetic Sand set sold for $15 during Black Friday. That was about 12% less than the month before.

A decent discount, on the face of it.

But $15 was also roughly its usual price. And the same product had sold for just $7 at another time of the year.

Kinetic Sand, over one year
  1. 1A month before the sale$17
  2. 2Black Friday 2021$15 (−12%)
  3. 3A few months later$7

The advertised discount compares $15 with the price a month earlier. Over the whole year, $15 was an ordinary price, and the sand sold for $7 a few months later.

The two brief jumps above $22 go off the chart. Source: Keepa price history, Amazon.ca, Black Friday 2020 to 2025.

LinkedInX

Conversely, we saw promotions that were real opportunities. A Samsung TV sold for $350 during Black Friday 2020, compared with about $400 usually, saw no noticeably lower price that year.

Two products on sale. Two very different realities.

That is why we chose to analyze historical prices rather than advertised discounts.

In our study, a “good price” is a price among the cheapest 25% of days in the year. A “best price, or close to it” meets a stricter test, tied to the yearly low.

That distinction changes how the results read: during Black Friday, 44% of observations are at a good price, but only 23% at the yearly low or close to it.

The question then becomes very concrete: how do you know whether the price in front of you today really deserves a trip to the checkout?

Fortunately, there are now several tools to answer it.

How do you find a real bargain? Four tools worth knowing

1. Our study: find the best months to buy, by category

Before you even start watching a specific product, it can be useful to know the times of year when its category is generally at its most advantageous.

That is one of the reasons we built an interactive explorer from our study.

It lets you compare the 19 categories analyzed, see how prices move over the months and gauge what the big sale periods are worth.

The results hold a few surprises.

November stands out for toys and video games. For baby products, it is October instead. Sports and outdoor goods show a more favourable profile in June.

And in several categories, no month stands out enough to recommend a specific period.

Of course, these historical trends do not predict the price of your next purchase. But they tell you when it may be worth starting to watch the promotions.

2. Amazon: check the price history directly

Since November 12, 2026, Amazon has been rolling out a new feature in Canada that should make life easier for bargain hunters.

With Alexa for Shopping, its AI-powered shopping assistant, you can view up to 365 days of price history for eligible products.

In practice, you open a product page and select the “Price History” option, where it is offered. You can view the changes over 30, 60 or 365 days, or ask the assistant directly how the price has moved.

It is a small improvement that can make a big difference.

Before being won over by a 40% discount, you can see whether the product really cost more over the past few months.

The tool is still built into a platform whose goal is to sell. But historical data give shoppers one more point of comparison, available at the moment they need it.

3. camelcamelcamel: watch a product without thinking about it every day

To go a little further, I also like the idea behind camelcamelcamel (opens in a new tab).

It works simply: you copy the address of an Amazon product, then look at its price history.

You can see the changes over time, spot the periods when it was cheaper and understand whether the current price is unusually attractive.

But the feature I find most useful is the alerts.

Say you want to buy a laptop listed at $1,200, but you would be willing to buy it at $950.

Rather than going back to check its price every week, you set an alert at $950. If the tracked price reaches that threshold, you get a notification.

You no longer need to guess whether Black Friday, Boxing Day or some random day in February will be the best time.

You have decided in advance on the price that suits you.

And you can simply wait.

4. Auto-Buy: what if an assistant could buy at the right time for us?

This is where things start to get particularly interesting.

Amazon now offers, notably in the United States, a feature called Auto-Buy, built into its shopping assistant.

The idea goes a step beyond price alerts.

You identify the product you want to buy, then set the maximum price you are willing to pay. If the conditions are met, the assistant can make the purchase automatically.

No more watching the promotions every day or rushing because a sale ends in a few hours.

This option is not yet confirmed in the Canadian rollout of Alexa for Shopping, however. In Canada, Amazon has announced price history and plans to add price alerts.

Still, the shift is telling.

For years, e-commerce platforms have worked to make our purchases easier and faster. Assistants that can take action, sometimes called AI agents, could now let us delegate part of our shopping: watch a price, wait for certain conditions, then buy.

It also raises an interesting question: how far are we ready to let an algorithm decide when we spend our money?

After all, an automatic purchase is still an expense, even when it is triggered at the best price.

So, is Black Friday still worth waiting for?

After six years of data, what I take away most is that our relationship with bargains deserves a little more nuance.

Yes, Black Friday remains a good time to buy. Good prices are more common than in normal times, and the indicators we studied do not show the decline many imagine.

But the results vary a great deal from one product to another. In some categories, waiting for November brings a clear advantage. In others, the difference is small, or even impossible to demonstrate.

We also compared Black Friday with Boxing Day and Prime days. There too, the results are far from identical. All these analyses, with their charts and methodology, are available in our full study.

Above all, this work leads me to favour a fairly simple approach.

When I want to buy something, the first reflex should be to look at how much the product usually costs. Then, to decide on the price I am really willing to pay. And, if the purchase is not urgent, to let the tracking tools do their work.

We won’t always find the lowest price of the year. There will still be missed bargains, unexpected promotions and purchases we could have made for a few dollars less.

But it is entirely possible to make good decisions without knowing the future.

And if a product didn’t interest us before it was marked 40% off, it may be worth asking whether it really interests us now.

About the study. The analysis covers 1,055 distinct products sold on Amazon.ca, representing 2,215 product-year observations from 2020 to 2025. The data come from Keepa price histories. The sample is not representative of Canadian retail as a whole. Some short-lived promotions, some coupons and some member-only prices may not be captured. See the full method

Gabriel Tassé is Vice-President, Strategy, Innovation and Thought Leadership at Tink and teaches at HEC Montréal.

One more thing before you go…

This article is part of my Turbulences series (in French).

If you enjoy unfiltered reflections and bold explorations of the digital trends shaking up our world, from marketing to AI to the environment… then Turbulences is for you.

A newsletter designed as a spontaneous conversation, where ideas take flight before they are perfectly polished.

Share the article